Skip to main content

Foundation for Law and International Affairs Comments on the Charity Law of the PRC (Draft)

This post introduces a set of comments on the Charity Law of the PRC (Draft) I have prepared together with the Foundation for Law and International Affairs

The comments can be accessed here:

As those who have been following the vicissitudes of China's civil society sector will know, a Draft Charity Law was submitted to the National People's Congress at the end of October, and released for public comment.

During the time I spent in Hong Kong, I was fortunate enough to have had an opportunity to more closely observe the chances as well as the hurdles Chinese civil society organizations face every day. 

Earlier, I have stated how the decision to establish Party groups in Chinese and foreign civil society organizations is a much needed move to once and for all set straight the relationship between civil society organizations, and the local leadership. Knowing and addressing the needs and demands of all stakeholders is essential to ensure a smooth management and implementation of cooperation projects. The Foreign NGOs Management Law marked a phase where foreign donor agencies and NGOs may have wanted to pause and ask themselves whether, in trying to help address the needs of Chinese society, they were speaking a language compatible with the language spoken by Chinese stakeholders.

The Charity Law (Draft) signals our ingress in a different and much brighter phase, one in which we will witness a renewed emphasis on the role charities can play in social governance. After a 10 years gestation, the Charity Law will encourage a greater transparency and accountability of foreign as well as domestic NGOs. The focus on these two fundamental values will improve the contribution of China and foreign's civil society sector to good governance. The Draft law addresses these and other themes, yet other possibilities deserve a closer consideration. 

Preventing corruption and money laundering, defining a clearer role for foreign NGOs, tapping Chinese NGOs potential to promote global good governance are some of the areas that deserve further attention. These and other areas are explored in the Foundation for Law and International Affairs comments on the Charity Law. I hope the comments will be useful to the National People's Congress, the Ministry of Civil Affairs, domestic and international donors and practitioners, as well as the academic community. 

The Foundation for Law and International Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan, nonprofit organization mandated to promote academic and public discourse at the intersection of law and international affairs. The core vision of FLIA is to promote international cooperation and public dialogue through the development of new ideas and collaboration with various academic, governmental and civil actors. The mission of FLIA is to facilitate international scholarly activities, conduct high quality, independent research and policy analysis, engage in public education and awareness-building programs, as well as amplify the voice of the rising generation. 

A heartfelt thank you goes to the China Law Translate community, for an excellent translation of the Draft Charity Law. 


Popular posts from this blog

A Question From Douglas Elmauer

This post has been written in response to a question Douglas Elmauer (Escola de Direito de São Paulo, Brazil) asked following the Rountable on The Implications of the 19th Communist Party Congress.
To what extent does Chinese openness to the global capitalist market help in the process of democratization and in strengthening the "rule of law" that provides legal security for foreign investors and companies? Perhaps the progressive economic opening may one day irritate politics to the point of a constitutional rupture in the future.

Dear Douglas,
thanks for this very thought-provoking question. A conventional response would rely on either of three contrasting approaches to the free market as an agent of democratization:
A first approach would confirm this nexus, and then proceed to look for the most appropriate locus of irritation in China’s political system, in the hope a constitutional rupture may lead to democratization and to stronger guarantees for multinational corporations…

UN Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment - Suggested Revisions

On October 10, 2017, Professor John Knox, the Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment released a newsletter where  comments on the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment were solicited
I was honored to produce and submit a commentary together with Professor Larry Catà Backer, under the auspices of the Coalition for Peace and Ethics. The executive summary of a much longer commentary on the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment, and a table of our suggested revisions to the Draft Guidelines are reproduced below.

Executive Summary
The Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment are based on articles 4, 5, and 7 of Resolution 31/8, and articles 5, 6, and 7 of Resolution 34/20 (Human Rights and the Environment). They summarize the basic human rights obligations of States on environmental matters.
The adoption of the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment will provide an important opportunity to seek to advance the conceptio…

LIVESTREAM- Implications of the 19th Chinese Communist Party Congress — November 3, 2017–10:00 AM EDT

Join a group of scholars from the United States, Europe, and China on a roundtable on the implications of the 19th Chinese Communist Party Congress.

Date: November 3, 2017 Global Times: 10:00 AM EDT (New York)03:00 PM CET (Rome, Berlin, Stockholm)10:00 PM CST (Beijing, Shanghai, Hong Kong)Concept Note and List of Participants — English and Chinese Primary Sources on the 19th Congress of the Chinese Communist Party Access Link