Skip to main content

Relaunching the Scientific Outlook on Development?

--> Last week, the anniversary of the founding of the PRC was
October 2, 2016 People's Daily Editorial 
marked by two events that went more or less unnoticed. On September 29, General Secretary Xi Jinping held a
speech at the Symposium on Studying the Selected Works of Hu Jintao. On October 2, the People's Daily published an editorial on 'A Major Result in the Sinification of Marxism'. This post examines the October 2 editorial. An abridged translation of Xi Jinping's speech is available here, and my comments on the speech will soon be published on this blog.

The editorial was exclusively focused on the Scientific Outlook on Development. It specified what the Scientific Outlook on Development is, what requests it poses, and why it is important.

China Millennium Bell. Image Courtesy Wikimedia Commons
The October 2 editorial was published by an author writing under the pen name 钟言闻实 Zhongyan Wenshi

The first character -  zhong - conveys the idea of time, of time that passes, of timing,and also a bell. 言 stands for words, while 闻 in this context could refer to news, or to the hearing of news. The final character, 实 is truth and honesty. It is not uncommon for important editorials to be signed by one (or multiple) authors writing under a pseudonym. The characters chosen to compose the pseudonym do not convey any deeper or 'hidden' message inside the text. The poetic or allegorical names chosen to sign editorials convey an authorial intention to readersThe authorial intention behind this article could have been that of 'timing words and listening to truthful news'.  

The words to be spoken at a precise point in time - the anniversary of the founding of the PRC - and which are truthful words to be carefully listened to, are the words Scientific Outlook on Development.

Western analysts have long struggled to attribute a precise, univocal meaning to what in an earlier paper I have called "ideological formulas". These ideological structures, however, are polysemic, they carry multiple meanings at the same time. In fact, according to the October 2 editorial, the Scientific Outlook on Development is:


(a) born from the practice of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics. It emerged from attempts at meeting challenges ranging from natural disasters, as the Wenchuan earthquake, to terrorist attacks and financial crises. It took shape under the guidance of earlier ideological guiding principles - Marxism-Leninism, Mao Zedong Thought, Deng Xiaoping Theory, and the Important Thought of the Three Represents

(b) "a major result of the sinification of marxism in the new century."

(c) "an ideological guiding principle the CPC must uphold for a long time"

(d) "a guiding principle created mainly by Hu Jintao"

Also, the Scientific Outlook on Development conveys an essential meaning, a core position, a fundamental request, a basic method and a spiritual essence (第一要义、核心立场、基本要求、根本方法、精神实质).

Its essential meaning is Development. 

Its core position is 'humanity as the root' (以人为本): benefitting the People, realizing, protecting and developing the fundamental interests of the broadest majority of the People, respecting the People as as autonomous subject (主体), promoting a comprehensive development, whereby development is for the People, relies on the People and is enjoyed by all the People.

Its fundamental request is a comprehensive and coordinated sustainability of development.

Its basic method is 'overall planning which takes all the factors into account' (统筹兼顾) - the ability to handle every kind of contradictions and problems without losing one's strategic direction; an awareness and appropriate treatment of the major relationships of the cause of Socialism with Chinese characteristics. These major relationships are: urban-rural development, local development, economic development, domestic development, opening up to the outside world, centre-local relationships, and the harmonization of various kinds of interests.

Its spiritual essence is emancipating thought, seeking truth from facts, advancing in accordance with the time, being realistic and pragmatic (解放思想、实事求是、与时俱进、求真务实).

Development, sustainability, realism and pragmatism are to find their expression in the economic development strategy mentioned by the editorial, in the concept of People's Democracy, in the Socialist Core Value System, in social harmony, environmental protection, national defense and military affairs, in the One Country Two Systems policy, foreign relations, and in Party building. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Internship Opportunities at the Foundation for Law and International Affairs

I am delighted to share a call for internship issued by the Foundation for Law and International Affairs, an organization I am a proud member of.



FLIA Internship Opportunity

We are looking for interns from all over the world.

Who we are and what we do
FLIA is an independent nonprofit organization established in Washington, DC in 2015. As an educational and consultative think tank, FLIA is devoted to promoting global communication, cooperation, and education in the field of law and international affairs. The areas on which FLIA focuses include comparative law and culture, international crime and judicial assistance, courts and tribunals, social responsibility and sustainable development, global economics and world trade, international relations and multilateral diplomacy, global security and governance, and human rights. FLIA conducts various programs such as FLIA Conference, FLIA Dialogue, FLIA Insight, FLIA Youth, FLIA Publication, and FLIA Blog. 
Why be a FLIA intern
If you are seeking to…

A Question From Douglas Elmauer

This post has been written in response to a question Douglas Elmauer (Escola de Direito de São Paulo, Brazil) asked following the Rountable on The Implications of the 19th Communist Party Congress.
To what extent does Chinese openness to the global capitalist market help in the process of democratization and in strengthening the "rule of law" that provides legal security for foreign investors and companies? Perhaps the progressive economic opening may one day irritate politics to the point of a constitutional rupture in the future.

Dear Douglas,
thanks for this very thought-provoking question. A conventional response would rely on either of three contrasting approaches to the free market as an agent of democratization:
A first approach would confirm this nexus, and then proceed to look for the most appropriate locus of irritation in China’s political system, in the hope a constitutional rupture may lead to democratization and to stronger guarantees for multinational corporations…

UN Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment - Suggested Revisions

On October 10, 2017, Professor John Knox, the Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment released a newsletter where  comments on the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment were solicited
I was honored to produce and submit a commentary together with Professor Larry Catà Backer, under the auspices of the Coalition for Peace and Ethics. The executive summary of a much longer commentary on the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment, and a table of our suggested revisions to the Draft Guidelines are reproduced below.

Executive Summary
The Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment are based on articles 4, 5, and 7 of Resolution 31/8, and articles 5, 6, and 7 of Resolution 34/20 (Human Rights and the Environment). They summarize the basic human rights obligations of States on environmental matters.
The adoption of the Draft Guidelines on Human Rights and the Environment will provide an important opportunity to seek to advance the conceptio…